7 min read

Secondary Trauma and Compassion Fatigue in Helping Professions

Secondary Trauma and Compassion Fatigue in Helping Professions

Over the past ten years, I have collaborated and worked—both in individual sessions and in groups—with professionals in the mental health, social work, education, and medical fields: psychologists, school counselors, coaches, psychotherapists, teachers, social workers, and doctors. I have listened to life stories and professional challenges, witnessed successes and difficult moments. I have seen the depth of dedication, empathy, and involvement in this work—and, at the same time, how invisible the emotional cost of sustained engagement with the suffering of others can be.

Many of these professionals, sooner or later, come to face secondary trauma, compassion fatigue, or burnout. Beyond terminology, these translate into very real experiences: emotional exhaustion, difficulty concentrating, irritability, detachment from loved ones, loss of motivation, and a diminished sense of meaning in their work. These phenomena do not stem from a lack of strength or resilience, but from the fact that caregiving work demands a profound emotional investment, and our vulnerability is often shaped by how we learned, from childhood, to care for others while ignoring our own needs.

It is worth noting that the terms secondary trauma, secondary traumatic stress, compassion fatigue, and vicarious trauma are sometimes used interchangeably, although they highlight different aspects. What they share is the recognition that bearing witness to the suffering of others can generate real and significant stress—stress that deserves to be understood and addressed with the same seriousness as direct trauma.

Secondary Trauma and Vicarious Trauma

Secondary trauma occurs when we are indirectly exposed to another person’s traumatic experiences—through listening, supporting, counseling, or intervening. The brain and body may react as if we were direct witnesses, and symptoms can resemble those of post-traumatic stress disorder (PTSD): intrusive thoughts, nightmares, hypervigilance, and avoidance of certain stimuli.

It is considered an occupational hazard in fields such as mental health, medical care, social services, emergency response, and education. Research shows that a significant proportion of professionals are vulnerable: between 6–26% of therapists working with trauma survivors and up to 50% of child protection social workers report high levels of secondary traumatic stress or PTSD-like symptoms.

Vicarious trauma describes the gradual, profound changes in how a professional perceives the world, themselves, and the meaning of life as a result of repeated exposure to traumatic material. It can affect one’s sense of safety, trust in others, self-esteem, capacity for intimacy, and perception of personal control. Unlike secondary trauma, which focuses on immediate emotional and physiological reactions, vicarious trauma refers to enduring cognitive and existential changes.

In practice, the two phenomena often overlap: a professional might experience nightmares and anxiety (secondary trauma) alongside a gradual loss of trust in people (vicarious trauma).

Compassion Fatigue – The Emotional Cost of Caring

Compassion fatigue, a term popularized by Charles Figley, refers to the emotional, physical, and sometimes spiritual exhaustion that arises when we consistently support people in distress without adequate recovery resources.

It manifests as reduced empathy, emotional detachment, irritability, frustration, cynicism, withdrawal from relationships, and decreased professional engagement. The Professional Quality of Life (ProQOL) model defines compassion fatigue as consisting of secondary traumatic stress and burnout. It develops gradually, fueled by ongoing exposure to suffering and a lack of balance between giving and replenishing.

It is essential to understand that compassion fatigue is neither inevitable nor a sign of professional inadequacy. With early recognition, appropriate support, and self-regulation strategies, professionals can maintain their capacity to be present and empathic over the long term.

Burnout – Professional Exhaustion

Burnout is a syndrome recognized by the World Health Organization, characterized by emotional exhaustion, depersonalization, and a reduced sense of personal accomplishment.

Conceptually, burnout is distinct from secondary trauma and compassion fatigue, though it often overlaps with them. Burnout is primarily caused by organizational and contextual factors: heavy workload, lack of resources, insufficient managerial support, role conflicts, and excessive bureaucracy.

Signs of burnout include:

  • Persistent fatigue, even after rest
  • Declining motivation and enthusiasm
  • Reduced performance
  • Difficulty concentrating
  • Increased irritability
  • Feelings of uselessness or lack of purpose

Why is it relevant in trauma work?
Burnout can increase vulnerability to secondary traumatic stress and vicarious trauma because it depletes internal resources and reduces recovery capacity. Conversely, the presence of secondary trauma can accelerate the onset of burnout.

Organizational risk factors identified in the literature include:

  • Lack of leadership support
  • Excessive workload
  • No time for breaks or emotional processing
  • Insufficient resources
  • Limited opportunities for professional development
  • Rigid or toxic organizational culture

Recognizing burnout as a problem is not solely the individual’s responsibility—it is also the responsibility of the organization.

Why We Choose Helping Professions

Many helping professionals developed, from an early age, an exceptional ability to attune to the needs of others. For some, this was a way of adapting to emotional deprivation, unmet needs, or family contexts where safety, love, and approval were earned by caring for and attending to others.

This capacity is undoubtedly a virtue and a valuable resource in helping work, but it can also become a source of difficulty. The tendency to constantly prioritize others’ needs can lead to neglecting one’s own needs, difficulty setting boundaries, people-pleasing behaviors, and even chronic emotional deprivation.

Psychoanalyst Karen Maroda notes that professionals who engage emotionally in an authentic way often have the most positive impact—yet it is precisely this involvement that can lead to exhaustion if their own needs are not recognized and honored. Lack of awareness can result in impulsive reactions (acting out) or withdrawal and self-sabotage (acting in).

Compassion Satisfaction

Compassion satisfaction is the positive side of working in helping professions. It refers to the sense of fulfillment, meaning, and energy that comes from knowing your work makes a real difference in the lives of others. It is the opposite of compassion fatigue and acts as a protective factor against emotional exhaustion.

In the Professional Quality of Life model developed by Beth Stamm, compassion satisfaction is defined as “the pleasure you derive from being able to do your work well.” Professionals with high levels of compassion satisfaction often report:

  • A sense of contributing to others’ well-being
  • Strong intrinsic motivation
  • Greater resilience to stress
  • A clear sense of personal and professional purpose

This positive state does not eliminate stress or challenges, but it creates a balance that enables sustained empathic engagement. Paradoxically, deep involvement in others’ suffering can bring profound meaning—provided there are support systems and self-care practices in place.

Ways to cultivate compassion satisfaction:

  • Recognizing and celebrating small successes at work
  • Staying connected to personal values
  • Receiving and giving positive feedback
  • Maintaining supportive relationships with colleagues
  • Practicing gratitude and acknowledging your positive impact

Research shows that professionals with high compassion satisfaction have lower rates of burnout and vicarious trauma, and report a better quality of professional life.

Resilience

Resilience is the ability to cope with adversity, adapt, and sometimes transform as a result of challenges. It does not mean the absence of suffering or stress, but rather the ability to recover and continue functioning despite difficulties.

Characteristics of resilient individuals include:

  • Cognitive flexibility: the ability to view situations from multiple perspectives
  • Emotional regulation: managing intense emotions without being overwhelmed
  • Purpose and meaning: clarity about personal values and motivation
  • Support networks: trusting relationships that provide emotional and practical support
  • Self-compassion: treating oneself with kindness, especially in difficult moments

Resilience in helping professions is not only a personal quality but also a professional competency that can be cultivated through: regular reflection on the impact of the work and adjustment of coping strategies, acknowledging and normalizing emotional responses and anchoring in compassion satisfaction—remembering why you chose this work.

Factors that support resilience:

  • Individual: physical health, education level, problem-solving skills, realistic optimism
  • Relational: support from colleagues, supervisors, and community
  • Organizational: empathic leadership, development opportunities, a culture of learning and support

Resilience is not static—it can grow or diminish depending on context, resources, and experience.

Post-Traumatic Growth (PTG)

Post-traumatic growth refers to the process by which a person experiences significant positive change after facing an extremely difficult event. Introduced by Richard Tedeschi and Lawrence Calhoun in the 1990s, the concept does not deny suffering, but shows that from the struggle with trauma, new perspectives, resources, and meanings can emerge.

Domains of PTG include:

  • Greater appreciation for life
  • Improved relationships—deeper connections, greater empathy
  • New possibilities—discovering opportunities or new life directions
  • Increased personal strength—more confidence in one’s ability to face challenges
  • Spiritual or existential change—a deeper understanding of life’s meaning

In helping professions, practitioners may experience vicarious resilience—developing their own resources and confidence by witnessing the resilience of their clients or beneficiaries. Being present for others’ positive transformation can inspire personal growth and reinforce one’s sense of meaning and motivation.

It is important to avoid turning PTG into a form of “toxic positivity.” Post-traumatic growth does not exclude pain or suffering; they can coexist. The process cannot be forced—it is unique to each person and may take considerable time.

Prevention and Self-Care

Preventing secondary trauma, vicarious trauma, and compassion fatigue is not a luxury—it is an essential part of professional hygiene in helping fields. Self-care is not just occasional relaxing activities, but an ongoing, planned strategy adapted to personal needs and work context.

Personal level:

  • Self-awareness: recognizing early signs of stress and exhaustion (e.g., irritability, sleep disturbances, emotional detachment)
  • Nervous system regulation: practices such as conscious breathing, gentle somatic exercises, mindfulness, or walking in nature
  • Healthy boundaries: clear separation between work time and personal availability
  • Recovery rituals: adequate, quality sleep; balanced nutrition; regular movement; activities that bring joy
  • Social support: regular connection with trusted friends or family

Professional level:

  • Supervision: regular access to individual or group supervision for processing difficult cases in a safe space
  • Debriefing: structured sessions after emotionally intense events
  • Continued education: training and resources that develop trauma competencies and self-regulation skills
  • Work–life balance: planned vacation and leisure time without guilt

Organizational level:

  • Culture of mutual care: leadership that fosters openness, support, and collaboration
  • Adequate resources: sufficient staffing, realistic timelines, appropriate equipment and infrastructure
  • Recognition and appreciation: positive feedback and formal acknowledgment of effort
  • Wellness programs: institutional initiatives that support physical and mental health of staff

Prevention is most effective when it combines individual measures with organizational support. Focusing solely on individual responsibility can lead to blaming professionals while ignoring structural factors.

Conclusion

Working with the suffering of others is both a gift and a responsibility. To continue being there for others, we must also be there for ourselves: listening to our bodies, acknowledging our needs, respecting our boundaries, and nourishing our inner resources. Self-care is not selfish—it is the foundation on which the capacity for long-term care is built.

Sources:
Figley, C. R. (1995). Compassion fatigue: Coping with secondary traumatic stress disorder in those who treat the traumatized. Brunner/Mazel.

Gilbert-Eliot, T. (2020). Healing Secondary Trauma: Proven Strategies for Caregiver Stress and Compassion Fatigue. PESI Publishing & Media.

Maroda, K. J. (2002). Seduction, Surrender, and Transformation: Emotional Engagement in the Analytic Process. Routledge.

Pearlman, L. A., & Saakvitne, K. W. (1995). Trauma and the therapist: Countertransference and vicarious traumatization in psychotherapy with incest survivors. W. W. Norton & Company.

Quitangon, G., & Evces, M. (Eds.). (2015). Vicarious trauma and disaster mental health: Understanding risks and promoting resilience. Routledge.

Rout, U. R., & Rout, J. K. (2002). Stress management for primary health care professionals. Springer Science & Business Media.

Saakvitne, K. W., Pearlman, L. A., & Traumatology Institute. (1996). Transforming the pain: A workbook on vicarious traumatization. W. W. Norton & Company.

Saakvitne, K. W., & Pearlman, L. A. (1996). Compassion fatigue, countertransference, and vicarious traumatization: A training manual for psychotherapists working with sexual abuse survivors. Sidran Institute.